The Indian Express has realized that two topic specialists, believed to be answerable for controversial questions in CBSE’s Class 10 and Class 12 Class 1 exams, have been faraway from the paper-setting panel by the board. The board has additionally constituted a committee beneath the chairmanship of former controller of examination Pavnesh Kumar to overview its paper-setting course of.
Two main controversies had been seen within the Term 1 board exams held in November-December 2020. The first was on a multiple-choice query within the Class 12 sociology examination that mentioned: “Under which government did the unprecedented level and spread of anti-Muslim violence in Gujarat take place in 2002?” The choices given to reply this query had been: “Congress”, “BJP”, “Democratic” and “Republican”.
The second was the Class 10 English check, which featured a understandable passage in a set of query papers, which was criticized as being regressive and offensive to ladies due to the “lack of parental authority in the home”. and “Wife’s Liberation”.
The concluding paragraph of the controversial comprehension passage learn, “What people were slow to see was that the wife’s emancipation destroyed the parental authority over the children. The mother did not exemplify the obedience to which she Still trying to insist … in bringing the man down from his pedestal the wife and mother deprived themselves, in fact, of the means of discipline.”
After the sociology examination, the board had put out a press release on Twitter stating that the query “violates the guidelines of external subject experts for setting up the question paper” and it’ll “take strict action against the responsible persons”. Following the English examination controversy, the board issued a press release expressing remorse over the “unfortunate incident”.
For every topic, the board organizes two panels to set the query paper – one of many paper setter and the opposite of the moderator.
“We had been partaking the providers of two paper setters on an settlement foundation due to their experience and expertise. It was determined that we’d not use their providers. They are nicely versed of their work and can proceed to stay of their establishments. The questions weren’t ‘flawed’ however they weren’t according to self-discipline,” mentioned a CBSE official.
The query on Gujarat riots was taken from a paragraph from NCERT Class 12 Sociology textbook ‘Indian Society’.
After dealing with criticism over the English comprehension passage, together with within the Lok Sabha, the board had made a press release that it will “constitute an expert committee to thoroughly review and strengthen the question paper setting process, so that such incidents are avoided”. the long run.”
“The committee will look into the method totally and see what must be achieved. If you take a look at the present system, there are literally sufficient checks and balances, however new conditions are rising and at occasions you need to put together with new methods of allocating work,” mentioned a member of the committee constituted.
A CBSE official mentioned that in view of the course wherein the board needs to maneuver forward within the examinations, there’s a want for overview. “We will see many questions not from textbooks in future as we are trying to move away from rote testing. This calls for more clarity in the guidelines for settling,” mentioned the official.
,
With inputs from TheIndianEXPRESS
