The Gujarat High Court on Thursday dismissed the state authorities’s plea looking for modification of its current order which had stayed the operation of Section 5 of the brand new anti-conversion regulation.
Section 5 of the Gujarat Freedom of Religion (Amendment) Act, 2021 states that spiritual clergymen should take prior permission from the district Justice of the Peace for changing any individual from one faith to a different.
In addition, one who has been transformed can also be required to “send an intimation” to the District Magistrate in a prescribed kind. A division bench of Chief Justice Vikram Nath and Justice Biren Vaishnav, after listening to the arguments of State Advocate General Kamal Trivedi, stated, “We do not find any reason to make any change in the order passed by us on August 19.”
Trivedi, on behalf of the state authorities, advised the bench that part 5 of the Gujarat Freedom of Religion (Amendment) Act, 2021 was in drive for the reason that unique regulation got here into drive in 2003 and has nothing to do with marriage.
He tried to persuade the judges that the clause on Section 5 would, in truth, stay in drive solely when your complete regulation was in drive, and that nobody would method the authorities to hunt permission earlier than changing.
On August 19, the High Court stayed sections 3, 4, 4A to 4C, 5, 6 and 6A of the amended Act for additional listening to, saying they “won’t be conducted merely because marriages are of one religion”. is solemnized by the individual. Without drive or inducement or fraudulent means to an individual of some other faith and such marriages can’t be referred to as marriages for the needs of illegal conversion”.
Trivedi advised the court docket that the phrase “marriage” shouldn’t be utilized in part 5 and it offers with the permission of the district Justice of the Peace for conversion earlier than or after marriage, and even in instances with out marriage. .
“Since Section 5 is barred, no one will come for permission, even if it is a voluntary conversion without marriage. They would say that the High Court had stayed the rigor of Section 5. This is for proposals where everything is done voluntarily. This order means that the entire law is now stalled,” Trivedi stated whereas urging the bench to carry the keep on Section 5, rectifying the earlier order.
“The different sections which have been barred are these associated to marriage, whereas part 5 is for authorized voluntary conversion. Under that part, if somebody goes to the priest, then the priest has to take permission. It offers with legitimate conversions. Why ought to a piece coping with legit conversions be stopped?” Trivedi requested.
However, the bench advised Trivedi that it was his personal interpretation that the court docket had stayed the prior permission half for every kind of conversions.
“If a bachelor wants to convert, he will need that permission. We haven’t kept it. We have banned the conversion of religion only through marriage. This is what we have said in the order,” Chief Justice Nath stated whereas dismissing the state authorities’s plea.
The Gujarat Freedom of Religion (Amendment) Act, 2021, which penalizes conversion of faith by drive or fraud by way of marriage, was notified by the BJP-led state authorities on June 15 this yr.
Similar legal guidelines have been made by the BJP governments in Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh as effectively.
Last month, the Gujarat chapter of Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind filed a petition within the HC, claiming that some amended sections of the state’s new regulation had been unconstitutional.
.
With inputs from TheIndianEXPRESS
